Energy transition architect Will Toor’s new podcast series promises a behind-the-curtain look at the state’s big pivot. You can listen, read or both.

 

by Allen Best

Eight years ago, Xcel Energy rented the west side of the Denver Museum of Nature and Science. On that day in December 2018 company executives had come from their headquarters in Minneapolis to announce they were getting out of coal in Colorado and the seven other states where they operated.

Jared Polis had been elected Colorado governor the prior month after campaigning on a platform of 100% emissions-free energy by 2040. “Elections have consequences,” he said during his turn at the lectern.

Indeed they did. Democrats, in control of both branches of the Legislature for the first time in several years, set out to push the energy transition at a brisk pace. The pivot was already underway in 2019 but under Polis it has accelerated. The job won’t be completed for at least a few decades. But, in Colorado, these last years have been a remarkable run.

Will Toor has been at the center of this pivot. As director of the Colorado Energy Office, he takes orders from Polis, but he is a very big thinker in his own right. You might call him the architect-in-chief.

Toor also happens to be a very bright but also interesting individual. For example, he had dropped out of middle school in seventh grade and entered Stanford when he was 16 — to go to graduate school. He has a doctorate in physics. His career path for several decades, though, has revolved around public policy. He was mayor of Boulder and then a Boulder County commissioner before working with the advocacy group, Southwest Energy Efficiency Project, where he was in charge of that group’s advocacy of decarbonized transportation.

But here’s another item on his resume. When still young, he spent part of a winter herding sheep on Douglas Mountain, near Dinosaur National Monument, in far northwest Colorado. He’s physically robust, the sort of guy who will take a bus from Boulder, where he lives to the Eldora ski area and hoof it up to the Continental Divide crossing at Rollins Pass.

He’s still backpacking despite a mountaineering accident several years ago that caused him to tumble 1,000 feet down a steep snowfield, breaking his leg and leaving him with a permanent limp.

As for minimizing his carbon footprint, Toor has an EV but quite a lot of the time he gets around on a bicycle after catching a bus.

Toor spoke on Thursday evening at the Denver museum, this time on the east side. He is the central figure in a series of podcasts called High Altitude, Low Carbon: Colorado’s Climate Story.

The first hour-long podcast has Toor talking with two governors, Polis and former Colorado Gov. Bill Ritter, about Colorado’s energy transition. Seven more are to follow, each one dropping on a successive Wednesday until early January. Among those Toor interviews are at least three current or former state legislators, two people from transportation, a couple from energy utilities, somebody from the oil and gas sector, and somebody from the agriculture economic sector.

The podcasts have been produced by the Colorado Energy Office in conjunction with the museum-affiliated The Institute for Science & Policy. Kristen Uhlenbrock, the institute’s director, introduced him at the celebration, telling about their first meeting at a bar during a conference in 2018 and the story he shared with her.

Kristen Uhlenbrock, executive director of The Institute for Science & Policy

“The story ended with a lot of interesting characters and some hitchhiking and some lack of clothes,” she said. “But it made me realize that he’s such a human. No matter how brilliant he is and how dedicated he is and how passionate he is to do things, he is very much a human. And he’s very good at storytelling.”

“In my defense,” said Toor when he took the microphone, “the lack of clothes was not voluntary. It was at gunpoint. If you would like a full story, it’s at the bar afterwards.”

Toor is uncommonly even-tempered, at least in my experience. Once I heard him get slightly grumpy in answering endless and repetitive questions during a legislative hearing. Another time, after a speaking engagement, he didn’t seem to welcome my question when I was at the end of a long line of inquisitors. Mostly, he’s quick with a smile or laugh. Given the enormous responsibilities of his work and the balancing act with family, that persistent good cheer is almost astonishing.

At the Denver museum, Toor described the public temperament in 2019 when he became the director of the energy office.

“It was kind of a moment in time when there were just real opportunity and real public support for getting a lot done. And then over the ensuing eight years, it’s just sometimes almost a blur.”

Toor seems to have initiated the idea of podcasts. His energy office then approached the institute, which has a mission statement to be a “catalyst for thoughtful dialogue, working toward solutions on society’s greatest challenges with scientific thinking, empathy, and inclusivity.”

He described the podcast conversations as an attempt to shed more light on the complicated behind-the-scenes work of policymaking that he said the public rarely gets to see or hear about. “Our goal with High Altitude, Low Carbon is to pull back the curtain through conversations with key elected officials and government, advocacy, utility and business leaders.”

Colorado should be regarded as a national leader in this transition. Ritter said research by the Center for the New Energy Economy, which he founded and then directed for many years, left no question about that. “Colorado would absolutely be considered somewhere in the top five, maybe even the top three” among states, he said.

Former Colorado Gov. Bill Ritter

For those engaged in this energy pivot in Colorado, much of what was explained during the first podcast is not new. Still, at times, there is likely to be new information, such as what Polis said about Colorado’s ability to meet to the 2040 decarbonization goal he had asserted in 2018. Others might be surprised to hear Toor and Ritter wish for more bipartisanship. It makes for better laws, said Toor.

The intended audience is not necessarily energy wonks. In doing podcasts, Toor and his team at the Colorado Energy Office believe they can gain a larger and perhaps younger audience.

With these podcasts, Toor also hopes to influence and inform other states in their energy transitions. In Toor’s eyes, Colorado is an interior state and one with a significant oil and gas sector. Even if the state’s politics have shifted from purple to solidly blue in the last decade, it could be seen as a place other states not on the East or West coasts will want to study and, at times emulate.

As for Colorado’s journey, Toor acknowledged being influenced by California but he also reported an effort to maintain a distance. “When we would steal a policy idea from California, we really usually tried not to tell anyone that that’s where it came from,” he said.

In the initial podcast, Toor talks first with Ritter, the governor of Colorado from 2007 to 2011. Toor acknowledges the building blocks in place before 2018. Most demonstrable was voter approval in 2004 of the citizen-initiated Amendment 34, which required Xcel Energy to get 10% of its electricity from renewable sources by 2015. Xcel fought it — then set out to comply. That vote, in turn, gave Ritter confidence to run on a platform emphasizing renewable energy. “It gave me a sense that people were ready for a different conversation about energy.” He bucked his campaign advisers and made renewable energy a central part of his TV advertising.

Among the 57 bills related to the energy transition passed by state legislators during Ritter’s four years as governor were steeper requirements for increasing levels of renewables for Xcel.” And two different CEOs at Xcel have told me they would never have gotten to where they’re getting to without having a standard put in place of 30% by 2020,” Ritter tells Toor in the podcast.

Colorado, when Ritter became governor, had capacity from wind turbines for 200 megawatts of electrical generation. Now, it has somewhere between 5,000 and 5,500 megawatts. During the same time, the price of wind-generated electricity has dropped from 11 cents per kilowatt-hour to 2 cents now. Scale matters, and of course, the scale involves many places beyond Colorado.

Progress slowed during the eight years when John Hickenlooper was governor, although even then there were key steps. Colorado became the first to regulate methane emissions from natural gas infrastructure. The renewable standard was upped again. Clean car standards were adopted.

Ritter said the first work in this energy transition was bipartisan. Then, it became more difficult after about 2008 as the Tea Party ascended in power. “We felt some of the strain in Colorado. We still had a Democratic majority in both houses, so we were still able to accomplish some things. But I was disappointed that we’re not doing it in a bipartisan fashion.”

“I felt that Gov. Hickenlooper had a pretty difficult time in trying to get bipartisan support, even though there were people I know inside the Republican Party who did support the transition or at least were thinking about what that transition looks like over the next 10, 20, 30 years.”

Polis replaced Hickenlooper as governor, and if Toor has been the chief architect of this transition since 2019, Polis has had his own very big ideas. Toor related that he sometimes got text messages as late as midnight, suggesting this or that. One of those late-night messages was about geothermal. The first greenhouse gas reduction roadmap in 2020 overseen by Toor made no mention of it. Why didn’t Colorado push this?

Indeed, Colorado began pushing it in 2022, when Polis famously made “Heat Beneath Our Feet” his mission while chair of the Western Governors Association. Geothermal was also growing, but the state funding and effort has clearly accelerated the adoption of thermal energy networks in schools and other public buildings. State aid has also spurred work, still unrealized, of producing electricity from heat found deeper underground.

Those deep in the energy trenches might wish for more peeks behind the curtain in this series, if the first podcast is an indication. Mention is made in the Toor-Polis conversation about the wish of some environmental organizations for a sweeping measure to spur climate change. Toor called it “one rule to rule them all, where our state air quality commission would have the absolutely authority over emissions and probably would have required a cap-and-trade program.”

Polis let it be known quickly that he would have none of this approach. His approach was sector-by-sector and incremental in nature.

This conversation still isn’t over, as evident in the fact that governor-elect Phil Weiser has mentioned “cap and invest constructs” — a phrase used by Sen. Mchael Bennet in his campaign for the Democratic nomination — as something to be studied.

Colorado Gov. Jared Polis spoke at the National Association of State Energy Officials conference in Boulder during late October as Will Toor, director of the Colorado Energy Office, looked on.

In talking about decarbonization strategies, Polis also shared a statement indicating his semi-libertarian ways that at times have exasperated some in environmental groups.

“Personally, I like the ones that lean into individual choice and freedom,” he said. “I was thrilled to sign the (bill) that allows for porch solar. You can plug in and power your iPhone charger or whatever you want with solar on your porches. It can’t be banned by the HOAs or buildings.”

Toor said he also loved the plug-in solar bill. “I have a 23-year-old daughter who thinks most of what I do is really boring. She’s like, ‘Dad, you’re just a bureaucrat.’ But she got really excited when I described that bill because as a renter, she was like, ‘You mean as a renter I can get solar?’”

Another theme has been affordability. “Do not allow people to make an argument that things like affordability, reliability, and sustainability are mutually exclusive, said Ritter in advice to incoming-governor Weiser. (But see an upcoming story n Big Pivots about growing tensions around affordability).

As for the 100% by 2040 goal that Polis espoused in his 2018 campaign, it looks now like Colorado will fall short. He blames primarily the policies of President Donald Trump, especially the tariffs. A turnaround in federal policies could bring that 2040 within reach, he said, but right now 96% for electricity may be tops.

Some will probably critique the choices of interviews. Duane Highley, the chief at Tri-State Generation and Transmission since 2018, will be on a podcast, but not Mark Gabriel from United Power or Bryan Hannegan from Holy Cross Energy. Lots of considerations, including time-constrained schedules, played into who got air time with Toor.

Aside from this difficulty, the first podcast provides little discussion of failures or difficulties. Don’t expect a he-said, she-said accounting of this energy transition. To be clear, this is mostly cheerful and celebration.

As for the behind-the-curtain stuff, no, it’s not there much, at least in the first episode. But Ritter does talk about the need for compromises. “Not everything is a perfect solution to carving out the future that you want. There are a lot of things that you have to ultimately do and think about that might involve some compromise, but the question is: is it a step forward? Does it take you forward, and does it take you forward quickly enough to address some of the things you’re trying to do?”

I have to think Ritter was referring to the compromise that allowed Xcel Energy to convert two of its coal-burning plants, Cherokee and Pawnee, to natural gas.

At the museum celebration, Ritter also talked about long-term vision.

“It’s not easy in governing to say this will matter 20 years from now, because so many people are not concerned about 20 years from now. They’re concerned about the things that are going to immediately hit them, particularly when you have an affordability crisis,” he said.

Ritter talked about the merging of climate and energy policies. He credited the Polis team, state legislators and others with thinking 20 and 30 years out. It can be thankless at times, creating policies that attempt to anticipate that far into the future.

“It’s not easy to do it and say it’s going to matter in 2046,” he said. “But we did things in 2006 that certainly mattered in 2026, and it’s important just to keep that mindset going forward. And the Weiser administration, I feel pretty comfortable, is going to be a part of that.”

Here is the link to the first podcast of High Altitude, Low Carbon.

 

Allen Best
Follow Me
Latest posts by Allen Best (see all)
Big Pivots

Subscribe to free Big Pivots™e-magazine

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!