Utility said it couldn’t make its 100%-by-2030 goal. Fair enough, some say. But should it set an interim goal to help spur its journey?
by Allen Best
In December 2018, representatives of the four northern Colorado cities that collectively constitute the Platte River Power Authority approved a conditional but ambitious goal. They wanted electricity that the utility provided to be 100% emissions-free by 2030.
In October, directors of the still coal-reliant Platte River adopted a revised strategic plan. This plan maintains the goal of achieving a 100% non-carbon energy portfolio. However, it removes any date.
“I’ve said from the beginning that it’s not if, but when, we get there. Our non-carbon goal remains unchanged,” said Jason Frisbie, the general manager and CEO of Fort Collins-based Platte River, in an announcement shortly after the board decision.
“As we continue pursuing our energy transition objective, it is essential that we appropriately balance decarbonization efforts with the reliability and affordability our owner communities expect. The updated policy reflects that commitment and provides a framework for responsible decision-making as technologies, markets and customer needs evolve.”

Jason Frisbie, the chief executive officer of Platte River, spoke in September at the celebration of the completion of Black Hollow, the giant solar complex east of Fort Collins, within the municipality of Severance. A battery storage project is now under construction adjacent to the solar panels.
Platte River reported no dissent among board members, nor was there immediate community pushback noted in the member jurisdictions of Fort Collins, Loveland, Estes Park, and Longmont.
But some community members, including at least one former director of Platte River, contend that the new strategy falls short.
“You have to set aggressive goals or things don’t happen,” said Ross Cunniff, who was a Platte River board member representing Fort Collins from 2019 to 2021.
Cunniff, a member of the Fort Collins City Council from 2013 to 2021, concedes the difficulty of the arbitrary 100% emission-free goal by 2030. Still, he says, he advocated for interim goals while on the Platte River board.
“I’m not talking about a moonshot goal. Interim goals need to be practicable,” said Cunniff. “But without having interim shorter-term plans, longer-term plans will never happen.”
Staff members at Platte River, he said, were driven almost exclusively by preserving reliability and affordability. “They didn’t like any hint of uncertainty in their plans.”
The debate in northern Colorado is a microcosm of other discussions about the energy transition across the state— indeed the nation and the world. A fundamental question is whether climate change poses such an extraordinary risk that utilities and the customers they serve should accept greater risks such as potential for loss of power on hot summer evenings.
That same question of tradeoffs is part of the current debate about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. As currently written, the bill would advance permitting for transmission. Many analysts believe improved transmission is crucial to decarbonizing the grid, but even some ardent decarbonization advocates find the cost to environmental protections proposed by the bill unacceptable.
A more nuanced question has to do with costs. Keeping the lights on at nearly all times in the case of Platte River involves investment in an expensive natural gas plant. One response is that the warming climate will result in financial costs no less real and almost certainly much higher if not quite as immediate. With that realization, the calculations look entirely different.
At some level, many utilities, regulators and legislative bodies are weighing these related calculations. What are the true risks and what are the real costs? Platte River and its four members cities are not particularly unusual.
Few of those who challenge the strategic plan question the aspirations of the four member cities or the utility’s staff members to decarbonize the utility. The differences are over pace and acceptance of risk.
Other reductions in Colorado
In Colorado, only a few smaller municipal utilities, most notably those serving Aspen and Glenwood Springs, can claim to have 100% carbon-free electricity. This is achieved, at least in part, by ordering electricity from suppliers like you would organic food from a restaurant menu.
Somewhat different is Holy Cross Energy, which serves areas around Aspen, Vail and other communities downstream along the Colorado River. Through September, it was at 88% emission-free energy.
Ratcheting down emissions is harder for larger utilities who have more customers. Colorado legislators, in setting greenhouse gas reduction goals during 2019, recognized this difficulty, mandating only 80% reductions in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 — but compared to 2005 levels. By that arithmetic, some utilities will be only 70% emissions-free energy by 2030.
Bidding goodbye to coal entirely in Colorado is proving somewhat more difficult than expected two or three years ago.

Colorado Springs Utilities said it needed to keep its Ray Nixon coal plant available until 2032, and Colorado legislators during the last session agreed.
Colorado Springs Utilities said it had to keep its Ray Nixon coal plant operating until 2032, and state legislators this last session agreed. Xcel Energy in 2025 was forced to delay the retirement of Comanche 2, which had been set to close last December. It is now to remain open until at least December 2027 and possibly beyond. The delay appears to be at least partly a response to the unreliability of another coal unit, Comanche 3.
For that matter, even those utilities such as Holy Cross that want to be 100% by 2030 acknowledge that an emissions-free electrical grid is still decades away. Holy Cross CEO Bryan Hannegan said at a forum in Vail several years ago that he expects natural gas will be part of Colorado’s electricity even at mid-century.
Several Colorado utilities have recently completed or are planning natural gas units. That includes Platte River.
Coal remains a large part of Platte River’s operation. On some recent nights in early November, it has produced nearly two-thirds of the electricity consumed by the four municipalities. Platte River operates Rawhide, a coal plant 20 miles north of Fort Collins that was commissioned in 1984.
In 2020,Platte River announced plans to close the coal plant before 2030, and that has not changed. It also has minority ownership of two of the coal-burning units at Craig scheduled to close in 2028.
In preparing to leave coal behind, Platte River recently added solar and is adding storage, too. At Black Hollow Sun, located east of Fort Collins, on the edge of Severance, Platte River has rights to the project’s 257 megawatts. Planning on that project began in 2019, and the second phase was only completed in September.
Work is now underway adjacent to Black Hollow on 100 megawatts of storage that will be capable of being discharged across four-hour periods.
At the Black Hollow ribbon-cutting, Frisbie said he is confident Platte River will get “well in excess of 80% non-carbon energy” by 2030 while maintaining affordability and reliability.
Reliability looms large
Reliability, particularly, looms large in the thinking of Platte River, as it does in every single utility in America. The utility, in announcing its new strategic plan, pointed to survey results that showed reliability was the top priority for 93% of residential customers and 97% of commercial customers. Affordability was also a leading concern.
“Reliability and affordability — and then green as long as it doesn’t sacrifice those,” said Gary Hall, the mayor of Estes Park and chair of the board of directors at Platte River in an e-mail shared with Big Pivots. “And we’ll stay on that path.”
To ensure reliability, Platte River plans to expand its capacity to burn natural gas as necessary to fill in the gaps of renewables. It already has two gas plants, with a combined capacity of 388 megawatts, adjacent to the existing Rawhide coal plant. Now, it is installing “five aeroderivative turbines with jet-engine style technology.”
“It’s not a gas plant,” a Platte River communications officer admonished Big Pivots, suggesting a sensitivity to the matter.
Environmental advocates hotly contested the proposal in hearings before Larimer County in 2025. They worried about contributions to northern Colorado’s notorious ozone pollution.

Platte River Power has gas-fired units and solar panels adjacent to its Rawhide coal-fired plant. Photo/Platte River Power Authority
The Larimer County Planning Commission voted 5-4 to recommend approval of the 1041 land-use permit. In April 2025, the county commissioners, with final authority, were unanimous, 3-0.
“The new gas turbines are NOT needed in the first place, because PRPA already has 388 megawatts of gas turbines, which are more than enough ‘insurance’ until more renewables and storage can be built,” insisted Kevin Cross of the Northern Colorado Alliance for a Livable Future in a November 2025 posting.
By then, the issue was whether the Colorado Air Quality Control Commission would issue a permit. It did so in April 2026. Two residents, from Longmont and Fort Collins, in May challenged that permit, reported the Loveland Reporter-Herald, alleging the state regulators improperly allowed the gas plant to avoid a stricter federal environmental review process.
Costs estimated in December 2024 at $352.9 million had ballooned to $623 million by October 2025, according to the Fort Collins Coloradoan.
Platte River emphasizes the flexibility of the 200-megawatts of gas-fueled generating capacity to meet peaks in demand. GE Vernova, the manufacturer, says it can “guarantee 90% base load within 10 minutes, while reducing fuel burn and start up emissions.” That fast start — more traditional gas technology can take between 10 and 30 minutes and coal plants can take 18 hours — complements renewable generation. Too, the aeroderivative turbines produce fewer emissions than coal or “existing frame (gas) units.”
In other words, if you’re going to burn fossil fuels, this causes fewest emissions and backs up renewables.
Construction, according to Platte River’s website, is to start in 2026. In October, Frisbie called it “the most critical and the most important project in Platte River’s history.”
Just exactly where is Platte River on its journey to emission-free electricity? Platte River provides real-time breakdowns of its energy sources but no monthly tally, unlike Holy Cross Energy. It does provide an annual report.
In 2025, fossil fuels remained a major part of electrical production for Platte River. The utility’s annual report said coal provided 41.2% of the electricity and natural gas 2.6%. But coal and gas may have been sources for electricity purchased from other sources, or 26.8% of the total electricity.
Renewables — wind (14.9%), hydropower (9.6%) and solar (4.9%) — were responsible for 29.4%. That compares with the 32% that Durango-based La Plata Electric reports as its power source on an annualized basis.
Looking ahead, Platte River has no immediate plans for more solar, according to a spokeswoman, but is “actively negotiating next steps for an additional wind project.” The utility’s integrated resource plan (page 111) had said that southeastern Wyoming and eastern Colorado were the likely sources. Transmission constraints would limit new wind to 200 megawatts of capacity from Wyoming, while eastern Colorado wind costs would be encumbered by charges for use of transmission lines by others.
Conditions of 2018 resolution
Platte River’s directors adopted their 100% by 2030 goal in December 2018, a time of heady ambition in Colorado. Jared Polis had been elected governor the prior month after running on a platform of 100% renewables. Xcel Energy then announced it was committed to getting out of carbon by 2050.
Boulder resident and solar entrepreneur Ron Sinton at the time told Polis that a more advisable goal was 90% to 95% given the cost and difficulties of 100%. Polis, he said, responded that President John Kennedy did not set a goal of 90% of the way to the moon.
The resolution by Platte River’s directors was heavily conditioned. It said advances must occur in the “near term” in nine areas to enable realization of that 2030 goal. For example, it said an organized regional market must exist with Platte River as an active participant.
That regional market arrived on April 1 in the form of Southwest Power Pool’s Western market, including Platte River. That launch has been somewhat less than smooth as evident in SPP’s call for Tri-State to crank up a retired coal unit at Craig. Colorado’s hottest summer record almost certainly played a role. Beyond that, some participants believe the SPP market, to be effective, needs more participants than it has in Colorado and two other states.

Transmission remains a question mark as Platte River and other utilities seek to decarbonize their power supplies, which requires better access to renewable sources across broad areas.
Among other advancements, the 2018 resolution said that battery storage performance must mature and the costs must decline. Plus, end-user storage must be available.
Battery storage was incipient in 2018. Just weeks before Platte River’s directors met, Colorado’s first utility-scale battery had debuted behind the United Power office along I-25, between Longmont and Firestone. Now, perhaps 1,000 megawatts of battery storage are spread across Colorado with much more planned.
Still absent, though, is longer-duration storage. Xcel plans a 100-hour iron-air pilot project at Pueblo. Federal funding was assumed, and after a hiccup with the change in presidential administrations, that funding was assured several months ago. Xcel now expects the Form Energy storage to be available in late 2027 or early 2028.
As for Platte River, its 2024 integrated resource plan (page 110) said Platte River is planning for 10 megawatts of long duration storage by 2030 and assumes the technology will be available for commercial applications by 2035.
In an e-mail, a Platte River staff member pointed out that the 2024 plan had concluded that 760 megawatts of new renewable energy proposed in the optimal new carbon portfolio would require a three-pronged approach to dispatchable capacity:
- Building out virtual power plants, or VPPs, within the owner communities. VPPs are networks of of small, distributed energy resources (DERs) such as rooftop solar installations, home batteries, and electric vehicle that are coordinated to work together to enhance efficiency on the power grid.
- Implementing both short and long-term energy storage when commercially viable; and
- Using the aeroderivative gas units. The 2024 plan suggested the gas units would be used at only 20% of capacity.
Benefit of the doubt
Platte River’s strategic plan adopted in October seems to have provoked exasperation among some residents who want to complete the decarbonization journey — soon. A more common response has been the argument for interim goals, mile markers on the journey.
Peter Eberle, of the Colorado Renewable Energy Society, said he and others understand that getting to 100% by 2030 is impossible. “No argument there,” he said. Reliability matters.
Given the uncertainties that make Platte River’s staff uncomfortable, Eberle is inclined to give Platte River the benefit of the doubt.
One of those uncertainties is what will happen on the federal front. The Trump administration has thrown obstacles in the path of new wind projects, even those in Colorado. It has also blocked the retirement of coal plants, including one unit at Craig. It also made noise about blocking retirement of a unit at Pueblo.
See: “Is Colorado project a victim of Trump ire?” Big Pivots, July 26, 2026)
“Implications of Michigan case for Craig coal unit” Big Pivots, Sept. 26, 2026)
The Southwest Power Pool is not fully on its feet. Platte River still needs to get familiar with how the Black Hollow solar installation works during all seasons. And improved transmission — considered by many to be crucial to get to decarbonization beyond 90% — remains a question mark.
However, given where Xcel expects to be by 2030 — it says it will achieve an 80% reduction from 2005 levels — and the statement of Frisbie at the Black Hollow celebration that Platte River expects to be above 80%, an interim goal would seem to be acceptable, said Eberle.
Platte River plans for the worst. That puts reliability at the top, followed closely by affordability. As for the environmental leg of this three-legged stool, it always has been just a little shorter.
“They are moving at the pace that is probably uncomfortable for them,” said Eberle,” but not fast enough for some of us in the community.”
- Is Platte River Power ambitious enough? - November 17, 2026
- Eric Blank and Colorado’s changing energy jigsaw puzzle - November 12, 2026
- A former Colorado governor’s advice to the next one - November 12, 2026


